Gratis verzending vanaf 30 euro binnen Nederland!
Winterselectie bij medaka: rijstvisjes in een ondiepe witte bak, van bovenaf beoordeeld op rugvorm

Winter Selection for Medaka: Who Stays, Who Goes

The first cold nights are coming, and then comes the question that returns every autumn: which fish get to go into winter? Winter selection for medaka is not a inspection for its own sake. It is about which fish will still be there in March. If a tub is too full going into the cold, you lose exactly the fish you wanted to keep.

The choice rests on three things: the back, the condition, and the breeding line the fish comes from. Size helps, but it is never the first argument. Below you will find how to keep to that order, how many fish remain per litre, and what to bring indoors when the frost arrives.

Why Not Every Medaka Makes It Through Winter

Medaka are tough. The Japanese rice fish, described in 1846 by Temminck and Schlegel, according to Wikipedia handles water from 0 to 42 °C and prefers 15 to 28 °C. That number is about survival, not reserve. A fish that got through the summer thin and stressed goes into the cold with no margin.

Cold water holds oxygen better, that is the good news. The bad news is that the bacteria in your filter and on your bottom are almost dormant at 4 °C. Waste is then not broken down but stored, and every fish adds its share.

In practice, the blow often falls not in January but in March, when the water warms up and the weak specimens succumb first to something that has been smouldering for months. Selecting in October is therefore also a measure for spring.

Winter Selection for Medaka: Back, Colour and Size

Winter selection for medaka begins with the back and ends with the size, in that order. The back tells you whether the skeleton is well formed, the colour or the line adds something, and the size tells you how much reserve is left. Whoever reverses the order keeps the biggest fish and throws out the best one.

Acht medaka van boven af in een witte sorteerbak
  • Back shape. Straight when seen from above, no kink, no hump, no sideways bend. This weighs the heaviest, because a crooked back cannot be corrected and often passes on to offspring.
  • Colour. Deep and even, not faded or blotchy. With glitter and albino lines, look at the coverage over the whole flank, not at one bright spot.
  • Size. Within the same age group, the larger fish, because they have more fat reserves. Seriously Fish gives 36 mm as the maximum, so the difference lies in millimetres.

The breeding line is your fourth, quiet criterion. If a fish comes from a spawn in which crooked backs appeared every round, then one beautiful specimen is no reason to defend that line. You do not keep a fish because it happened to turn out well, you keep it because its brothers and sisters did too.

How Many Fish May Go Into Winter: Litres per Fish

Winter selection for medaka starts with litres, not with feeling. The rule that works here: one fish per 2 to 3 litres of water at the moment the tub goes into winter. In summer it may be busier, because the water is warmer and the filter works faster. Scale back in October, not in December.

SeasonLitres per fishWhy
Summer1Warm water, active filter, fish grow
October1.5 to 2Metabolism drops, filter bacteria slow down
Winter2 to 3Barely any food, little oxygen under the ice

First work out your litres: length times width times depth in centimetres, divided by 1000. A tub of 100 by 60 by 40 cm is therefore 240 litres, which at 2.5 litres per fish means roughly 96 fish. That 96 is a ceiling, not a goal.

Count only water that is really deep. A rim of 10 cm does not count, and a tub that stands full to the brim with rainwater is not a winter tub. Do not be guided by what fitted in July.

Condition Above Size: What You Really Look At

You can see condition in four things: the belly line, the gill covers, the fins and the response to food. A fish that is hollow behind the head has no fat left. One proper look in a white tub with clear water tells you more than half an hour of squinting at a dark tub.

Set the fish apart in a transparent tub and look from above and from the side. Watch for scales that stand loose, white specks on the fins, red edges on the gills and a fish that keeps hanging at an angle. These are not winter candidates, even if they are otherwise beautiful.

Score with three words: keep, doubt, out. Anything you have to defend while looking is a doubtful case, and that goes to the indoor tub or to the clear-out tub. This keeps the decision quick and honest.

Inside or Outside: What Goes Into the Tub and What Does Not

Winter selection for medaka is not the same as picking out the most beautiful fish. The sorting that causes the least discussion works with three piles.

  • Stays outside: full, straight fish from the line that moved you forward this year, in a tub with the right density and a few bunches of oxygen plants.
  • Goes inside: the best young fish you want to let grow on, plus the doubtful cases you want to observe without them harming the group.
  • Goes out: crooked backs, visibly sick fish and specimens that add nothing to a line you already have.

Indoors does not need to be warm. A cool room of 15 to 18 °C, a tl or LED light for 8 hours a day and a sponge filter without strong current are enough; Seriously Fish gives 16 to 22 °C as the comfort zone. Feed twice a week in winter, and only what is gone within a few minutes.

The Selection Day Itself: Catch, Score, Decide

If the forecast for your region points to night frost, then it is time. The KNMI gives the forecast per region; inland, the first frost usually comes earlier than at the coast. Count two to three weeks before that first frost as your last moment; in autumn 2026 that usually means the second half of October.

Tafel met sorteerbakken en een schepnet op een herfstdag

On the selection day itself, winter selection for medaka is mainly logistics. Work in small batches, because judging a hundred fish at once leads to mistakes. Catch 15 to 20 fish, look at them, note your verdict and put them back or set them aside.

  1. Set out two or three holding tubs: one for keep, one for doubt, one for out.
  2. Catch in batches of 15 to 20 fish and keep them in clean water of the same temperature.
  3. Assess each fish first from above on the back, then from the side on belly line and fins.
  4. Note the number per tub and check afterwards whether you are still under your ceiling.
  5. Repeat the doubtful tub once, with fresh eyes.
  6. Put the final group into the winter tub and do not cover it completely straight away.

Use a small notebook or your phone, with tally marks per tub. Afterwards nobody remembers how many fish were in the doubtful tub, and that is exactly the tub you want to be able to account for.

What to Do With Removed Fish Without Regret

What you do not keep does not have to die. Most breeders in the Netherlands give surplus fish away through a club, a fair or a neighbour with a bigger pond. Be honest about the reason: a fish with a crooked back is a pet, not breeding stock, and the new owner may know that.

Sick fish never go in with other fish. Keep them apart, watch what happens and clear them out if it does not get better. For a fish with a serious deformity that no longer swims decently, euthanasia is the humane choice; do it calmly and never in the pond.

Some keep a separate tub for the fish that are not taking part. That is fine, as long as you do not forget them there: those animals also need water, shade and food now and then. A clear-out tub is not a solution, it is postponement with a date attached.

A Smaller Group of Better Fish Wins

Whatever winter 2026 brings, a smaller group of better fish almost always beats a full tub of doubt. You keep the line sharp, you keep your water clean and you keep in March the fish you deliberately chose in October. The sum is simple: fewer fish, more oxygen per fish, less waste per litre.

Winter selection for medaka costs you an afternoon and a few buckets. It yields a spring in which you do not have to guess which fish has suddenly gone, and in which the first eggs come from a line you chose yourself. That's the whole point.

Further Reading

FAQ: Questions About Winter Selection for Medaka

When do you start with winter selection?

Winter selection for medaka begins two to three weeks before the first night frost you expect in your region. In the Netherlands that is usually the second half of October, later at the coast than inland. Do not wait until the water drops below 5 °C, because then the fish is already dormant and you would be catching it unnecessarily.

May a fish with a slight back deformity stay?

Only if you have space and keep it apart. A slight kink does not get better in cold water, and the structure often passes on. If you have the choice, the fish with the straight back goes first.

How many litres of water do I really have?

Measure length, width and depth in centimetres, multiply and divide by 1000. Do not count water that is only 10 cm deep, because nothing swims there in winter. With 2 to 3 litres per fish you know your ceiling.

Can medaka overwinter indoors without heating?

Yes, a cool room of 15 to 18 °C is enough. They do not need to be warm; they need rest, light and clean water. Do not place the tub where the temperature fluctuates by more than a few degrees per day.

Receive a 10% discount on your first order when you sign up for our newsletter.

Write a comment

Je e-mailadres wordt niet gepubliceerd. Verplichte velden zijn gemarkeerd met *

Search for products (0)

Back to Top
Product has been added to your cart