The water in your tub cools quickly these days, and with it closes the last window in which you can still properly reach the bottom. Removing sludge before winter is not a chore for a nice Saturday, it is the difference between a bottom that rots for months and a bottom that rests. In a 150 litre tub every layer weighs more than in a large pond, because there is little water to absorb mistakes.
Why removing sludge before winter cannot wait
Sludge is the sum of everything that has sunk since spring. Leaves from the trees around it, spent aquatic plants, fish droppings, food that fell between the pellets, and a layer of dead plant tissue that slowly breaks down. You see little of it as long as the water is clear, but it is there, and it grows a little every week.
From early November leaves are added, you may still feed once a day, and the bacteria in the water work more slowly than in August. What you leave lying in autumn 2026 will be in the same place in spring 2027. Only then it is no longer leaves but a black layer that you can no longer catch with a net.
- Leaves and stems that sink to the bottom after the first night frost.
- Uneaten food, mainly pellets that stay caught between the plants.
- Fish droppings and the skins of moulting water fleas and snails.
- Dead leaves from oxygen plants that come loose in autumn.
What sludge does to your water under a closed layer of ice
Once a solid layer of ice lies on the water, the exchange with the air stops. No oxygen diffuses in any more, while the bacteria on the bottom simply carry on breaking things down. In the bottom layer of a still tub the oxygen content then drops to almost 0 mg per litre within a few weeks. That is exactly where your fish are in the cold, because they seek out the depths.

What remains is anaerobic rot. Other bacteria take over the work and produce methane, ammonia and hydrogen sulphide. The pH drops, ammonia rises and the water turns grey. A thick layer is fuel for that process, and removing sludge before winter takes that supply away. Above the ice you see none of this: the water can look clear while the bottom has been busy for weeks with a process that has no way back.
The Japanese rice fish occurs naturally in shallow, still water: rice paddies, ditches and small pools where the bottom warms in summer and cools in winter. It tolerates that change well, as long as the water stays open and there is oxygen nearby (Wikipedia, Seriously Fish). A thick layer of sludge takes exactly that away.
Hydrogen sulphide: the gas you cannot smell under the ice
Hydrogen sulphide smells of rotten eggs. That is its only advantage: as long as the water is open you can smell it and intervene. Under an ice layer the gas stays trapped in the water and its concentration rises steadily, with nothing to smell. Even at very low concentrations it damages the gills and disrupts the uptake of oxygen into the blood.
Your fish can then suffocate while there is still quite a bit of oxygen in the water. With medaka you rarely see it coming, because in cold water they move little anyway and often stay low in the tub. Watch for these signs when the ice has just melted or when you have kept a hole open:
- Fish that hang motionless just below the surface and gulp for air.
- Gills that look dull or brown instead of bright red.
- Slow to respond to food, or no longer responding at all.
- Fish lying on their side with no visible injury.
How to do the last bottom clean, step by step
You do not need an expensive pump to remove sludge before winter properly. A siphon hose, a bucket and half an hour of calm work are enough for most tubs and tanks. Work on a dry, mild day and keep an eye on the frost forecast from the KNMI in the Netherlands the first night frost usually comes well before mid-November, and after that the bottom can no longer be reached.

- First measure the water temperature. If the water is above 8 °C you can work calmly; below 5 °C you postpone the job to a mild afternoon.
- Remove leaves and plant debris from the surface with a net before you start on the bottom.
- Siphon the sludge off with a hose into a bucket. Leave the bucket for 24 hours, pour the clear water back and put the sediment on the compost.
- Work in sections. Do not empty the whole bottom, because you need the biofilm on the walls and the gravel for water quality.
- Top up with water of roughly the same temperature, so you do not give the fish a cold shock.
- Then test ammonia, nitrite and pH, and replace another quarter if any of the values is above the safe limit.
Leave your filter alone. A sponge filter that you clean under the tap in November washes away bacteria you badly need in spring. At most rinse it in a bucket of tub water. Then put a net over the tub, because one rainy, windy week otherwise fills the bottom with leaves again.
| Method | How well does it work | Effort | Suitable for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Siphon hose with bucket | Good, also sucks up fine sludge | Calm, half an hour per tub | Tubs and tanks up to 300 litres |
| Pond vacuum with suction nozzle | Very good on coarse debris | More hassle, needs power | Larger tubs and small ponds |
| Net with fine mesh | Moderate, only catches leaves | Almost nothing | Emergency measure just before the frost |
| Full water change | Thorough, but hard on the fish | A lot | A tub you empty anyway |
| Sludge breaker with bacteria | At most supportive | Almost nothing | Preventive in autumn, not a remedy |
Feed less over the coming weeks. Below 10 °C medaka need little, and what is not eaten sinks to the bottom, where it refills the layer you have just removed. Two small portions a week is plenty in November, and in frost you stop altogether.
A clean tub gets through winter much more calmly
The sum is simple: an afternoon of work in November against a spring in which you scoop dead fish out of the water. With a clean bottom, a hole in the ice and a filter that stays intact, you keep the oxygen level in your tub high enough to get through the darkest weeks. That is no guarantee, but it is the part you control yourself.
If you doubt whether your tub will make it, for example because it is shallow or stands in a corner where the ice lingers, then overwintering indoors is the safer choice. An unheated shed or garage where it does not freeze, with a tub of water and a sponge filter, is often enough for a handful of medaka. Remove the sludge anyway in that case, before the tub goes inside.
Further reading
- Algae in the medaka pond: what 16 years of research teaches
- Caring for medaka through the seasons
- DIY dip nets for medaka: 4 materials tested
FAQ: removing sludge before winter in a small tub
How often should I clean the bottom of a medaka tub?
Twice a year thoroughly, in spring and just before winter. Of those two, removing sludge before winter is the most important. In between, use a net to take out what is visible on the bottom, especially after a windy week or falling leaves.
Can I still remove sludge when there is already ice on the tub?
No, you are better off leaving it. You break the ice, cause pressure waves and startle the fish in water where they should use as little energy as possible. Wait for a mild day in February or March.
Why can I smell nothing when there is hydrogen sulphide in the water?
Because the gas stays in the water under a solid ice layer and does not reach the air. The smell only reaches you when the ice melts or when you make a hole. If you do smell it, assume the bottom has been without oxygen for too long.
Does an aerator or ice-free opening really help?
It keeps a spot open where gas can escape and where some oxygen can get in. It does not solve a thick layer of sludge, but it gives your fish air in the weeks when you cannot get to them.
Receive a 10% discount on your first order when you sign up for our newsletter.







Write a comment
Je e-mailadres wordt niet gepubliceerd. Verplichte velden zijn gemarkeerd met *